You are here to create positive change in the world.

It’s all about your purpose and money is not so important – right?

Wrong.

Money is the basis of our modern world and none of us can live without it. We certainly can’t live the kind of fulfilled lives we want to live without financial support. Yet many purpose-led women seem to have a problem with their money mindset…

It’s not just that they believe that “money can’t buy happiness”, it’s almost a rejection of the idea that money should be important at all.

Or maybe you DO recognise it’s important but you still feel “icky” thinking about it, or “squirmy” when it comes to talking about fees or asking for a raise?

So is this a “money mindset” issue?

“Money mindset” is so often a red herring

These are actually issues to do with power, being your own boss, and doing what you want in life.

Let’s dig in to these. (See if you recognise your money mindset being impacted by any of this)…

Money Mindset Myth 1: Money versus Happiness

While of course, money can’t buy happiness (not sure anyone ever said it could), it facilitates the basic essentials of life, like enough to eat and a comfortable, secure place to live.

Certainly, it’s important to keep an eye on priorities and balance how we spend our time.

And yes, it is true that you can be utterly miserable, working all the hours to pay for that big house and garden that you never have time to enjoy. That ain’t fulfilment. And you might absolutely feel locked into that merry-go-round, and if you are, then please get support to change things because you almost certainly can’t untangle that one on your own.

But at the other end of the scale, when you are in poverty, you have less disposable income for life enhancing stuff, and, less time, because you have to spend more time (and cognitive load) just living.

(For example, using public transport rather than driving; working two jobs to make ends meet; going to multiple shops to get the best deals; worrying; scrimping for larger purchases, either before if you’re saving up, or after to pay off credit that costs more when you’re poor).

That doesn’t sound much like happy or thriving to me.

You need money to access and participate in many life enhancing experiences

Things like travel, learning a new skill, doing yoga/dance/creative arts, having a pet, etc., etc.

Having time for fulfilling or life enhancing activities can also cost money, eg hiring a cleaner, or a babysitter. This is particularly an issue for women, who still, STILL, do most of the household chores and most of the childcare, and, most of the cognitive load-lifting required to manage it all. ¹Gender Divisions of Paid and Unpaid Work in Contemporary UK Couples by Anne McMunn, Lauren Bird, Elizabeth Webb, Amanda Sacker First Published July 25, 2019 as reported in The Independent On-line, July 26th 2019 https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/women-men-household-chores-domestic-house-gender-norms-a9021586.html

(You knew that already, though, didn’t you?)

Money can’t buy happiness, but it can buy security, opportunity, and access.

It can buy choices. And the power to make them. (Of which more below).

So next time someone tells you “you’re too money-oriented”, or “Money won’t make you happy”, remind them that they are privileged to be able to make that distinction.

Poverty won’t make you happy either.

The whole Money v Happiness thing is a limiting, invented, false dichotomy that we need to throw out of the window because it suggests that your only options are one or the other.

To break free from this insidious, fake, and privileged narrative, we need to look it squarely in the face.

Money Mindset Myth 2: Money versus Niceness

There are so many things that, apparently, “nice girls” don’t do. Women’s behaviour and appearance is constantly policed²https://www.kcet.org/shows/artbound/the-policing-of-women-then-and-now-and-how-to-curb-it. Money and how we spend it is one of those areas where, we are told, we have to be careful.

Not that long ago being openly interested in money was regarded as rather vulgar and not quite “nice”. This goes back to the days when grand families had credit accounts with the butcher, tailor, and cabinet maker. Cash was something that only the lower classes actually dealt in. And women in particular were not supposed be interested in earning money – to do so would be considered both vulgar, and unladylike, again not “nice”.

These social rules on how women are supposed to be continue, albeit less explicitly.

You might have grown up with messages like:

(nice girls) …don’t stand out
(nice girls) …don’t show off
(nice girls) …take care of everyone else’s feelings
(nice girls) …make do with what they’ve been given
(nice girls) …look good, but not TOO good
(nice girls) …don’t rock the boat
and underneath all that: be nice (or else)

These are the sorts of messages that lead to professional women in my LinkedIn feed talking about how they feel they have to justify everything they buy to the nth degree. Because to do otherwise would suggest they were “flaunting” it, and not taking care of how other people might feel about it and this would be “not nice”.

So it’s no wonder earning a good living and being open about it (or just feeling calm and confident talking about money) might leave you feeling uncomfortable.

This seems especially problematic if you make a living through helping others.

In fact I’ve heard many reports of women being told that they should give their thing away for free (or at least for less) because it’s “helping people” and obviously, helping people is the “nice” thing to do. (And women, in particular, are expected to help others.)

Here’s the thing – you are as entitled as anybody else to earn a good living from your skills and talents. Because you are as entitled as anyone else to be able to engage in life-enhancement. And choosing that doesn’t make you “nasty” or “unkind”.

Those aren’t the opposite of nice. Or at least not the sort of nice they mean by “girls should be nice”.

The opposite of that sort of “nice” is empowered.

Empowered to make your own choices, empowered to stand out, empowered to rock the boat, empowered to create change.

Breaking free from this all-pervasive “being nice” means examining how you feel about making money, spending money, and what you believe about what’s “nice” and what isn’t.

Which brings me to money mindset myth number 3…

Money Mindset Myth 3: Money and Power

Money and power often go together in ways that purpose-led, soul-fired women don’t agree with.

But there is more than one type of power. The most common type to which we are exposed is the “power over” type. This is where one person, or group, is dominant over another. The exercise of this type of power has led to wars and oppression, slavery, and other social inequities and injustices.

In the “power over” paradigm, money is concentrated in the hands of a few. And becomes a symbol of everything that is wrong with the world.

Selfishness, and conspicuous consumption, are turn-offs for folk who care about equality, freedom and living consciously. Money itself becomes fraught with uncomfortable feelings, and “icky-ness”.

Seeking to make more money, and, doing anything that shows that you have it, gets tangled up with not wanting to be seen as selfish, self-indulgent, or interested in “bling” for the sake of it.

And it’s very easy to get confused. We confuse selfish and self-led, self-indulgence and self-expression. “Nice” too often means powerless. No wonder we feel conflicted about money and power.

An alternative power paradigm

Instead of “power over” there is the “power to”. This also, as discussed above, requires access to money. Money gives you the power to feed your family. The power to walk away. The power to choose. And the power to relax. This form of power: the power to create, implement and choose, is life affirming because it rests in each of us, not just a limited few.

As Peggy Natiello puts it:

“It is through the exercise of power that we are able to take care of ourselves, to direct our lives, to grow, to survive. In itself power is neither good nor bad, but its practice can lead to either destruction or creative growth.”³Natiello, P (2001), “The Person-Centred Approach: A Passionate Presence – Chapter 6:Collaborative Power and Social Change”, PCCS Books

Here, money is a tool. It helps us create the kind of life we want. When used collaboratively with others, through our purchasing power, money can help us influence the kind of society we want.

Money, Happiness and the Power to Thrive

For sure, as flexible, inventive beings, when money is tight, we can take pleasure in being creative about life enhancing experiences. And not all life enhancing experiences need money. Yet neither do we need to be coy about, or ashamed of, our desire to thrive financially as well as in other ways.

Money, in and of itself, like power, is neither good nor evil. It’s what we do with it and to what extent it flows through our lives, or not, that matters.

That flow depends on a number of things, some to do with the systems in which we live, and others that are to do with our own relationship with money, power, and happiness.

Are you ready to do what you want in life? Check this out…

Originally published July 29, 2020, updated May 21, 2021